Tutorial:Total energy convergence

From OctopusWiki
Revision as of 12:02, 12 September 2016 by Fnog (talk | contribs) (→‎Convergence)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

In this example, for the methane molecule CH4, we will play a little bit with the spacing and the dimensions of the mesh.


In the input file we define a variable CH that represents the bond length between the carbon and the hydrogen atoms. From our basic chemistry class we know that methane has a tetrahedral structure. If we put the carbon atom at the origin, the hydrogen atoms have the coordinates given in the following input file.

CalculationMode = gs
Units = eV_Angstrom

Radius = 3.5
Spacing = 0.22

CH = 1.2
  "C" |           0 |          0 |           0
  "H" |  CH/sqrt(3) | CH/sqrt(3) |  CH/sqrt(3)
  "H" | -CH/sqrt(3) |-CH/sqrt(3) |  CH/sqrt(3)
  "H" |  CH/sqrt(3) |-CH/sqrt(3) | -CH/sqrt(3)
  "H" | -CH/sqrt(3) | CH/sqrt(3) | -CH/sqrt(3)

We start with a bond length of 1.2 Å but that's not so important at the moment, since we can optimize it later (for more information see the tutorial on geometry optimization). (You should not use 5 Å or so, but something slightly bigger than 1 Å is fine.)

Some notes concerning the input file:

  • We do not tell Octopus explicitly which BoxShape to use. The default is a union of spheres centered around each atom. This turns out to be the most economical choice in almost all cases.
  • We also do not specify the %Species block. In this way, Octopus will use default pseudopotentials for both Carbon and Hydrogen. This should be OK in many cases, but, as a rule of thumb, you should do careful testing before using any pseudopotential for serious calculations.


If you use the given input file you should find the following values in the resulting static/info file.

Eigenvalues [eV]
 #st  Spin   Eigenvalue      Occupation
   1   --   -15.988934       2.000000
   2   --    -9.064039       2.000000
   3   --    -9.064039       2.000000
   4   --    -9.064039       2.000000

Energy [eV]:
      Total       =      -219.01537542
      Free        =      -219.01537542
      Ion-ion     =       236.08498119
      Eigenvalues =       -86.36210292
      Hartree     =       393.44961913
      Int[n*v_xc] =      -105.38115372
      Exchange    =       -69.66918783
      Correlation =       -11.00060043
      vanderWaals =         0.00000000
      Delta XC    =         0.00000000
      Entropy     =         0.00000000
      -TS         =        -0.00000000
      Kinetic     =       163.96741296
      External    =      -931.84569058
      Non-local   =       -49.74424172

Now the question is whether these values are converged or not. This will depend on the Spacing and the Radius. The only way to answer this question is to try other values for these variables. We will start with the spacing. Since we are interested in the total energy of the system, we will look at the changes of its value. We will keep all entries in the input file fixed except for the spacing that we will make smaller by 0.02 Å all the way down to 0.1 Å. So you have to run Octopus several times (you can use the script from the Nitrogen tutorial) to get the following results.

Spacing CH4.png
#Sp    Energy        s_eigen   p_eigen
0.22 -219.01537542 -15.988934 -9.064039
0.20 -218.58289833 -16.068279 -9.054459
0.18 -218.20446230 -16.141917 -9.044887
0.16 -218.14597804 -16.151610 -9.043875
0.14 -218.14033248 -16.149049 -9.042342
0.12 -218.13672950 -16.149718 -9.042754
0.1 -218.12988174 -16.148881 -9.042024

If you give the numbers in the first two columns to gnuplot (or other software to plot) you will get a curve like the one shown on the right.

As you can see from this picture, the total energy is converged to within 0.1 eV for a spacing of 0.18 Å. So we will use this spacing for the next calculations, and play with the Radius of the box. We will change the radius in steps of 0.5 Å. Doing this we get

# Radius         Total Energy
2.5             -218.00107292
3.0             -218.17888864
3.5             -218.21314725
4.0             -218.21996456
4.5             -218.22132794
5.0             -218.22061906

If we again ask for a convergence up to 0.1 eV we should use a radius of 3.5 Å. How does this compare to the size of the molecule? Can you explain why the energy increases (becomes less negative) when one decreases the size of the box?

Previous Tutorial:Nitrogen atom - Next Tutorial:Centering geometry

Back to [[Tutorial Series:{{{series}}}|{{{series}}}]]